Completion Sign-Off & Disputes
Every Value Exchange ends the same way: each participating Node confirms that it received what was agreed. Nothing is held in custody and nothing moves automatically. Completion is a shared, recorded decision.
NodeHash never holds cash, credits, or deliverables. Protection comes from the agreed Proposal Snapshot, all-party sign-off, and admin review when something goes wrong.
1. The Value Exchange Lifecycle
Every exchange moves through a small set of states:
- Negotiating: Participants discuss scope in the exchange thread and propose terms. A new proposal resets everyone's agreement.
- Agreed: Every participant has agreed. The Proposal Snapshot is captured and the Haves involved are reserved for this exchange.
- Completed: Every participant has confirmed completion.
- Recorded: The outcome is added to each Node's exchange history and reputation, and reviews open.
An exchange can also end as Cancelled (a participant cancels before anyone signs off, or the proposal goes idle), Disputed (a participant reports a problem), or Defaulted (an agreed exchange goes idle past its delivery window).
2. Delivering the Work
Once the exchange is Agreed, each Node delivers its part as described in the snapshot:
- Coordinate in the thread: Share files, links, and updates in the exchange thread.
- Change terms together: Until anyone signs off, any participant can propose new terms. Everyone then agrees again.
- Cancel cleanly: Until anyone signs off, any participant can cancel. Reserved Haves are released.
3. All-Party Completion Sign-Off
When you have received what was agreed, open the exchange and choose Confirm completion:
- Inspect the work: Check files, links, or services against the snapshot.
- Unanimous completion rule: In a 2-Way exchange both Nodes must confirm. In a 3-Way exchange all three Nodes must confirm.
- Signing is final: Once any participant has signed off, the terms can no longer be changed or cancelled.
4. When Something Goes Wrong
If the work was not delivered as agreed, choose Report a problem instead of confirming:
- The exchange becomes Disputed: No one can complete or cancel it on their own.
- An admin reviews it: A NodeHash admin reviews the snapshot, the thread, and what each side reports, and may contact the participants.
- The admin decides: The exchange is marked Completed (delivered as agreed, or with agreed adjustments) or Cancelled (mutual cancellation, non-delivery, or a policy violation). Every decision is recorded in an audit log.
5. Reviews After Completion
After an exchange is Completed and Recorded, each Node can leave a review:
- Authentic feedback: Only Nodes that completed the exchange can review it.
- Honest history: Completed exchanges and reviews build your record over time. New Nodes start with an honest Insufficient History label.
- Public track record: New partners see your past reviews before they agree to work.